How Blog Comments Can Be Dangerous Sometimes

Did you ever guess that the comments at your own blog can completely kill your blog? No, I am not talking about the spam or irrelevant comments. A huge number of comments, genuine as well as extremely related to the article, can invite a Google penalization. So, how the comments at your own blog can harm you? Let me describe.

In late October of 2012, I experienced a huge drop in my blog (Tech Tips Geek) traffic. It jumped down to monthly Two lakhs page views from Four lakhs. I received an email in my Google Webmaster tool stating that there was a big traffic drop in my top performing pages due to site configuration change.

I was bit confused to figure out the meaning of “Site Configuration Change”. Henceforth, I started to guess what the heck damn thing I did with my blog configuration.

1. At first, I guessed, there should be some problem with WordPress as I upgraded it to 3.5 just 2-3 days before that alert from Google. I searched the web to find out if there was any bug with WP 3.5. No major feedback! I was frustrated as my traffic was going down and down.

2. Two months after the impact, I though there must be some Panda update which might have eaten my traffic. I started to pickup older articles which have almost no traffic. I could find 15-16 pieces of such content. I deleted them and decided to wait for some times. Also filed a lot of DMCA complaint against the scrapers. But, nothing did work for me. Traffic was more downwards which made me much frustrated.

3. Suddenly, I noticed that Google was delaying to index my new posts. I started checking the reason out again. But again, nothing found!!

4. Lastly, I opened Google Webmaster Tool for my site. I tried to check if there were too many 404 error pages (some time huge ‘404 Not Found’ links in your pages can discourage Google to index your pages). But there was no such broken links.

Eventually, I went for the “Fetch as Google” link at WMT to submit my new posts into Google index. Here, I discovered some dramatic result. The fetch results for my top pages contain a suspicious line. The line was like this:

“The page content that is displayed here may have been truncated. Please check the Help Center article about Fetch as Google for details about fetch limits.”

truncated-page

I noticed that Google is not reaching to the last of the page. It ends up far before the closing BODY and HTML tags. I was wondered! How does it possible!! When I am opening those pages in my browser and checking the source, it seems everything is fine there.

I started Googling and came to know that Google can fetch only less than 100 KB of the text version of a page. Curiosity was going high! I deeply noticed that Google is ending up in between the comment section of those pages which have a lots of comment.

Then, I decided to Fetch the pages which do not have too much comments. Yep! I got it!! The page was completely accessed by Google according to the fetch result.

Finally, I fetched all the pages of my blog which have more than 100 comments. The result was expected. They all were truncated due crossing the 100 KB limit.

Now things were clear to me. Google was trying to access those page and getting a truncated version. As everything about an authority blog is monitored by various tools of Google, my blog was not the exception. They send a message to me stating the configuration problem. It was my limitation that I could not figure out their hints.

And lastly, I received an alert message in my Adsense account asking to minimize the size of the HTML resource of my blog. They also gave a link of one the best performing page from my site as an example.

How did I get out of that problem?

After receiving the alert from the Adsense team, I was confirmed that the traffic drop in my site was due to page size. I followed some tasks in order to get out of the situation.

1. I deleted some comments which do not sound good or do not have any value.

2. I wiped out unusual div classes and sections from the comment part. For instance, if you use several div classes e.g comment header class, comment meta class, comment author class for the design purpose, you are nothing but creating a huge number of HTML resource for the page. Suppose, you’re using this code in your comment section:

<div class="comment-header">

<div class="comment-author-image">

<div class="comment-author"

</div>

</div>

</div>

<div class="comment-meta">

</div>

Here you should avoid the inner sections of the comment-header section. Because, those extra words (11 words) will be repeated 200 times if you have 200 comments at you blog. As a result your page will contain extra 200 x 11 = 2200 words as HTML resource which is much more than your content body has. It is recommended to remove those inner classes and design simply.

3. Installed W3TC (you should do it with caution as it may break up your site if configured improperly. Do not enable Database cache), configured it according to my need. I enabled the Minify option, activated comment removals, white space removals, line break removal options for HTML and CSS. Also enabled the Browser cache to set expire headers, HTTP compression etc.

4. Applied CSS sprite tricks to combine too many HTTP requests for the static CSS image sources.

5. I do host images at a subdomain for my WordPress blog for a better performance. I followed some tricks to optimized the images served from the subdomain.

As a result, my weighty pages became lighter, started performing great in Google Page Speed tool. According to the Google Page Speed tool, the score is about 92-93/100 for my pages.

Conclusion

Comment is an important part of your blog. It involves readers in conversations and asking for a solution of their problem. Again, relevant comments also help a bit in search engine ranking as well. But if the number of comments in a post exceeds hundred, you should close the comment for that post. Otherwise you’ll be a victim of high HTML resource issue.

Google Panda Penalty: Why Your Site Traffic Is Going Down

Google Panda PenaltyGoogle Panda penalty is one of the most talked term in Blog-sphere from last 9 months and we have seen lots of iteration in Panda. Now, when Panda was first released in Feb 2011, my blog traffic was slightly hurt and Panda being a new thing, I completely ignored it. Situation become worse when traffic went down from  18000/day to 4000. And in blogging, losing this much of traffic is like losing a fortune.

Last month in a bloggers meet, I met few pro-bloggers from India and one of the hot discussion topic was Google Panda Penalty. The sad part was, most of them were taking SEO and panda non-seriously, and none of them showed interest to fix it and recover from Panda. Many of them were like it’s just a tweak and with time, this will be fixed.  My answer: Want to recover from Panda, stop planning and start acting right away. The very first step to start with is: Why Google Panda updates are impacting your site. If this impact if good or bad. If after every update your traffic is going down constantly, it’s time to make a well-planned SEO strategy and work on it.

What is Google Panda penalty?

Before we move ahead with reasons for Panda penalty, let’s see what Panda is and what Google Panda penalty means. Google Panda is a major tweak in search engine algorithm, whose aim is to push the quality site up and lower down the ranking of low-quality content. Unlike all previous update, Google Panda is a domain level penalty, which means even if you have 5-10 low-quality content, your whole domain might get hurt because of this. The best way to check for Google Panda penalty is to open your Google Analytics and check these dates for any traffic drop or increase.

Google Panda update dates:

  • Feb 24th 2011
  • April 11th-12th 2011
  • May 9th 2011
  • June 18th 2011
  • July 23rd 2011
  • September 28th 2011
  • October 9th 2011
  • October 13th 2011
  • October 18-19 2011

In most of the cases, you will either notice an increase or notice a drop. Well, somebody loss is somebody gain here again. Now if you have seen a traffic drop, it means somewhere your site is lacking something. Or, you might be giving such signals to Google, which push your site down from the grade of quality site or trust-able site. Your first goal is to find what is it? Is it : Content quality-thin content, On site SEO, Too many ads, blog load time, design and many more. I will focus on some major points which will be helpful for you to lower down the impact of Google Panda penalty.

Site indexed pages

I’m not going to talk in-depth about your site SEO, as there are many resources on the Internet which will help to learn about on site and page SEO. Let’s see the other way, let’s check how Google indexes your blog. Go to Google.com and search for site:domain.com. Replace domain with your domain address. For ex: Site: ShoutMeLoud.com

You will find all the pages that are indexed in Google from your site. Quickly analyze what all pages are indexed and most important part is making sure none of your tags, categories, labels, search pages and any such part of your sites are indexed which doesn’t add any value.  Especially go to the last page and if it’s saying “Show omitted results,” click on that and see if your site pages are indexed with parameters like replytocom or iSalt or any other. If yes, well you need to work on the following factor:

  • Block wp-content, wp-includes access from Robots.txt
  • Add noindex meta tag to Tags, Categories, Authors and any such page which doesn’t add value.
  • Use  canonical tag.

Specially if you are tired of URL parameters and such useless link which is getting indexed in Google due to non-canonical tag, you should grab this .htaccess code for clean WordPress URL.

User behaviour

User behavior on your site is one major factor for search engine ranking now. Bounce rate, time on site are some factors that play a significant role here. If your site is cluttered with news from different niche, your site might have bounce rate. Also, no. of page views/visit is like 1 or 1.5; you need to work hard on your site design, content and architect. As, on an average as a user is reading your post and jumping away. The user might be leaving your blog instantly because of some of this factor: low-quality content, irrelevant page,  too many ads, difficult to read or slow load time. Your target should be lower down the bounce rate and increase the no. of page views/visit.

Thin or low quality content

If you have been writing all news post with no insight or little insight, your domain might be on the verge of Google Panda penalty. There is no exact definition of  Thin content, but here I’m going to give you a quick task, which will help you to understand the difference. Go to Google.com and search for “How to write SEO optimized content” and analyze the first five results. Rate all the five pages on the scale of 10 and once done, analyze why you rated someone higher and why lower. Obviously, all these five results are quality content but at the same time, you measured differently to all 5 of them. If you find an answer to this, you are on the right track and now read on.

From my experience. I was working on analyzing and finding thin content on my blog.

  • Most of my early days post which are usually 100-200 words and most of them are outdated.
  • Too many meta Keywords
  • Too many use of H3 tags
  • Announcement post which dies after some time. For ex: Hostgator June 2010 discount coupon.
  • Pages with high bounce rate.
  • Useful topic but without any insight.
  • Long meta description
  • Page load time
  • Duplicate content (PR, news posts)

Now, once you have found out all thin content on your blog, there are couple of actions which you can take:

  • Re-edit the posts
  • Noindex them and remove from Google Web search.
  • Delete them and remove from Google Web search.

If you are not an expert in this, you might like to hire any SEO expert or SEO company that can do all this thing for you. Talking about my actions: I mostly re-edited those posts that fall into the category of thin content but are useful. I added more information and republished it on the same day. You can see on such example on my post on BuySellads review. This post was earlier in 300 words and offer very less insight. Though the information was accurate but many more information can be added to it. I made all the changes and used LSI (Latent Semantic Indexing) to make the content more SEO friendly and boom, that post is now on the first page of Google.

Too many Advertisements

Without ads, it’s impossible to survive as a professional blogger. Google never says No to the ad but a big NO when it comes to too many ads.  If your ads are added in a way, which clutter the site design or you are adding too many ads around the post, you might be standing in the danger zone. Especially, if you are in the practice of adding ads in between the post. This is one of the must things that you should not do. Make sure, you don’t have too many ads above the fold and not too many ads around the content. Check 5 Profitable ways to monetize your blog without banners.

Site SEO

People are speculating that Panda means the death of SEO, which is not true at all. Panda enhances the complete algo of Google search and makes it better. There are many safe SEO practices that everyone should follow for example: Canonical URL’s, backlink building, Sitemap, Site Architect and other SEO checklist. Your on-page SEO also plays a great role here. If you have never done SEO optimization of your website, you might be missing a big chunk of traffic and most important your site might not rank well in search engine.

There are many other factors like Page speed, too many poor backlinks, spun content, too many down times. The best way to judge your site, it let a layman browse your site. See how he takes the action and if he go to other content or just leave. Is he facing problem understanding your content or he has some additional questions after reading your content?

One simple approach that I suggest you to keep is searching Google for the topic you are writing. Analyze the content of first 5-6 results and get an idea of what all you have to cover. Not to forget, even if you are writing complete detail, you might be missing the important on-page SEO factors like Keyword in the permalink, H1-H2-H3 tags and so on. You can probably consider purchasing plugins like Clickbumb, Easy WP SEO or ScribeSEO and optimize your content better on WordPress platform. I have been doing the same from last few months, and all such re-edited posts started getting their traffic back. One easy way to monitor is, grab  Keyword monitor software and check keyword position of any page before editing it, and compare it after 3 days of re-editing it. Adding more to it, after three days, do the social bookmarking submissions and promotion and check the Keyword position for that post.

I have seen my keyword position improving in following pattern 89>38>8. Before editing my experimental post, it was ranking at 89th position for my target keyword, after optimizing and adding more information, it jumped to 38 in 12 hrs. After social media submission, it jumped to 8th position. Though 3-4 posts are too less to come up with such conclusions but yes, it does help. The best way is to try it now and see it yourself.

There are few things that you should start doing from now on:

  • Write quality posts with complete detail.
  • Social bookmarking. (Very important)
  • Regularly update your blog.
  • A nice site layout with less clutter
  • Use Breadcrumbs
  • Utilize Youtube  & Flickr to drive more traffic.

Well, if you fall in the category of Panda beaten blogger, you might be having nightmare about your Blogging future. Though, there is no 100% recovery but once you start recovering from Panda penalty, you will be getting more targeted traffic than before and your earning will be back to normal, even with less traffic.

  • Recommended reading: How to recover from Google Panda effect.

Do let us know if Panda hurts your domain? What all strategies are you taking to gain your traffic back?